Safety Moment #15: Common Process Safety Hazards (Part 3)

HAZOP

Common Process Safety Hazards

One of the philosophies behind Process Safety Management (PSM) is that each chemical process is unique. Therefore it is not possible to have a prescriptive standard that tells operating companies what to do. Instead, companies have to identify the unique hazards associated with their facility, and then implement corrective actions based on a risk-ranking methodology. For this reason, facilities covered by PSM standards have to conduct a series of Process Hazards Analyses (PHAs), often using the Hazard and Operability (HAZOP) methodology.

Yet many hazards, particularly to do with utilities, piping, valves and hoses, are really not all that different from one facility to another. Therefore, in order to save time during the PHA and also to improve the quality of the analysis, it is useful to list and evaluate some of these common hazards before the PHA meetings start.

This Safety Moment is the third in a series that describes some of these common hazards. Discussed here are the HAZOP guide phrases ‘High Flow’, ‘Low / No Flow’, ‘Reverse Flow’ and ‘Misdirected Flow’. 

The first two Safety Moments in this series to do with Common Process Safety Hazards are:

High Flow

Generally, the phenomenon of ‘High Flow’ — in and of itself — is not inherently hazardous. Indeed high flow rates are often desired because they imply that the facility is maximizing production and revenues. Although high flow can occasionally create hazards, such as erosion of pipe walls or of a valve seat, its main effect in terms of process safety is to create secondary deviations such as ‘High Level’ in a tank. ‘High Flow’ can also lead to a ‘No Flow’ situation; for example, if a pump overspeeds, the sudden surge in motor amperage may result in the motor burning out leading to the flow stopping.

Low / No Flow

As with ‘High Flow’, the phenomenon of ‘Low Flow’ is not usually, in and of itself, hazardous. However, ‘Low Flow’ can create secondary effects. For example a low flow of cooling water in a heat exchanger can lead to ‘High Temperature’ of the process stream. ‘No Flow’ is usually more serious than ‘Low Flow’ because its occurrence implies a sudden cessation of a processing activity. Probably the biggest hazard associated with ‘No Flow’ is the possibility of it being followed by ‘Reverse Flow’ because the upstream and downstream pressures have equalized, or even reversed.

Both ‘Low Flow’ and ‘No Flow’ are usually caused by the inadvertent closing of a valve or the failure of rotating equipment such as pumps and compressors. Because such events occur quite frequently, most facilities have plenty of instrumentation and safeguards to respond to this scenario.

Reverse Flow

‘Reverse Flow’ can create high-risk hazards because it can lead to the mixing of incompatible chemicals or to the introduction of corrosive chemicals into equipment not designed for them. The causes of ‘Reverse Flow’ are usually a pressure reversal in which a high pressure section of the process loses pressure; process fluids then flow into that section back from low pressure sections of the process. (The occurrence of reverse flow almost invariably implies that a check valve and/or safety instrumented system has failed to prevent the event.)

The sketch shows a process consisting of three sections: A, B and C. The chemicals in Sections A and B are non-corrosive, so these two sections can be safely made of carbon steel. When the two chemicals are mixed in Section C they react to form a corrosive product, hence this section has to be made of stainless steel. If a reverse flow should occur from Section C to either A or B, then those sections would corrode, leading to loss of containment.

HAZOP Reverse Flow

 

Another feature of ‘Reverse Flow’ to watch for is that it may take some time for the operators to identify its occurrence, particularly if the flow measurement instrumentation is not set up to recognize the phenomenon. Moreover, experienced operators frequently have trouble visualizing ‘Reverse Flow’. They recognize the possibility of high and low flow because they have probably witnessed these phenomena, but reverse flow may be totally outside their experience. Hence, when the topic of Reverse Flow is being discussed during a HAZOP, the team leader should allow plenty of time for the team members to think through possible causes and consequences.

Misdirected Flow

‘Misdirected Flow’ occurs when a process stream is sent to the wrong destination. Like ‘Reverse Flow’ this deviation can create high risk scenarios because incompatible materials may be mixed with one another, or corrosive chemicals may be sent to areas without the correct materials of construction. Also like ‘Reverse Flow’ this scenario may be difficult to detect or diagnose.

Reference Material

Common process safety hazardsThe material provided here is extracted from Chapter 19 of the 2nd edition of Plant Design and Operations. Subsequent safety moments will discuss other common process safety hazards.